Measuring a Stirling engine with 1 watt power output and 1.5% efficiency

May 23, 2010 – 9:06 pm

The following is a transcript with still photos of the previous video on the same subject. I’ve included a few more notes about the engine, my model 3F.

This is a gamma configuration Stirling engine. I’m powering it with the heat from a 70 watt light bulb so that I can accurately measure the heat input.

The vertical shaft on the left connects to the power piston and the shaft on the right connects to the displacer. The power piston has a 1.25 inch diameter and a 2.5 inch stroke.

You can see the top of the displacer cylinder but the rest of it is covered up by the large metal cylinder packed with insulation. The displacer has a 1.75 inch diameter and a 2.5 inch stroke. The displacer cylinder has a 2 inch diameter and is approximately 12 inches long. The insulating cylinder around the displacer is 8 inches in diameter.

The thermometer measures the temperature near the hot end of the displacer cylinder. It reads 400 Fahrenheit or about 200 Celsius. In the original video the resolution is so poor you can’t read the thermometer. I’ve placed a better resolution photo of the thermometer next to it so you can see the approximate reading was 400 F (although it’s just at room temperature in this photo).

The torque measuring setup shown here is detailed in a previous post. Adjustment screws on the wood torque arm are set to squeeze the rotating shaft to achieve the desired torque value which is read on the scale below. Note that the torque force is transmitted through pins in the wood arm set at a 3 inch horizontal distance that makes the horizontal position of the arm support position on the scale uncritical.

I’m measuring the torque output of the engine with this setup. The scale shows a torque of 68 grams on a 3 inch arm or 68g x 3 inches / 454 (g/pound) =.45 pound-inches of torque. I lift the torque arm briefly to the check the zero reading.

This tachometer displays the engine speed in cycles per second times ten. So 33 means 3.3 hz or 198 rpm. More information on using a bicycle speedometer as a tachometer can be found in the low-cost tachometer post.

The 70w halogen light bulb is hidden up inside the insulating cylinder, but you can see the end of the socket for it here.

The watt meter shows the light is actually using 69 watts.

Here you can see the counter balance weights for the displacer and the crankshaft. The crankshaft drives the lever connecting to the power piston directly. The piston lever pivots freely on the horizontal shaft. A second connecting rod on the crankshaft drives an arm fixed on the horizontal shaft. The horizontal shaft then drives the displacer lever. This mechanism provides the 90 degree phase shift between the displacer and power piston.

The measurements shown are used to compute power and efficiency as follows:

Torque x 2PI = work per revolution
.45 lb-in x 2PI = 2.83 in-lb/revolution

(work/revolution) x revolutions/sec = work/sec
2.83 in-lbs/revolution x 3.3 revolutions/sec = 9.33 in-lb/sec

9.33 in-lbs/sec = .778 ft-lb/sec = 1.05 watts

Efficiency = power out/power in = 1.05 w/ 69 w = 1.52%

The measurements I’ve shown compute to 1.05 watts power output and an efficiency of 1.5%

  1. 4 Responses to “Measuring a Stirling engine with 1 watt power output and 1.5% efficiency”

  2. Hi Doug. Like your site, very helpful/informative esp. for a newbie like me. I’m giving a lot of thought to LTD heat engines at the moment. Nice to see somebody measuring power in/out, wondered if you were able to estimate what %age of the inefficiencies came from heatflow through the engine used inefficiently and what came from energy lost directly to the environment (the sort of thing your cylinder insulation is trying to minimise I imagine).

    By Alan on Jun 29, 2010

  3. Hi Alan. I will post my measurements and analysis of where the heat goes soon–I meant to do it earlier. I computed from measured temperatures that the convection and radiation losses from the bottom and sides of the insulated metal can are about 40W. I compute roughly 7W for the conduction losses through the displacer and displacer cylinder. I’ll put out more information on this soon.

    By admin on Jun 29, 2010

  4. Nice work.
    I have made similar efficiancy test on my water pump stirling engine.
    See: “Stirling engine water pump efficiency test 1.51W” on youtube at:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_65JfvC2qg&feature=related

    I reach 2.05% efficiency and 1.94Watt at +133Celcius.
    See the working princip animation at:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2Bbht7O2Hc&feature=related
    Best Regards
    Olle Welin
    olle_welin@hotmail.com

    By Olle Welin on Jul 21, 2010

  1. 1 Trackback(s)

  2. Jul 1, 2010: Solar Heat Engines » Blog Archive » Engine 3F Efficiency Analysis part 1

Post a Comment